Our Menu
Our Pie Flavors
10 inch - $25, $28, $30
5 inch - $6.50, $7.50, $8
Signature 'Be Happy' Cherry*
Apple Streusel
Awesome Apple*
Banana Cream
Blackberry Crumb
Blueberry Streusel
Bourbon Chocolate Pecan
Bourbon Pecan
Brownie
Bumbleberry
Cherry Crumb
Chess
Chocolate Chess
Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Custard (Plain or with fruit)
Icebox Lemon
Irish Oatmeal
Key Lime
Lemon Crumb
Loaded Chocolate Pecan
Loaded Pecan
Peanut Butter (Only available in 10 inch and 5 inch)
Pumpkin
Pumpkin Streusel
Raisin*
Seasonal flavors include: Gooseberry, Blue-Goose, Strawberry, Strawberries n Cream, Kae's Orange Dreamsicle, Rhubarb, Strawberry-Rhubarb, Peach, Mincemeat, Sweet Potato and Cranberry Pear
*$30 - Topped with a decorative double crust
Meringue, bourbon, top crust and some seasonal pies are $5 extra
Gluten sensitive flavors include: Banana Cream, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, Loaded Chocolate Pecan, Loaded Pecan, and Signature Cherry. Gluten sensitive pies are $5 extra for 10" pies and $1 extra for 5" pies.
Pie Bites
$3.45 each or $18 for 6 or $36 for 12
Our flaky 3-inch crust cups available in all flavors except peanut butter and meringue pies
Scrappies
$4 per 3 oz. bag
A bag of our delicious pie crust scraps dusted in a blend of cinnamon and sugar and baked to perfection
Scones
$3.45 each or $18 for 6 or $36 for 12
Current rotating flavor: Blueberry Lemon, Chocolate Chip, and Maple Pecan
'Grandma Good' Cookies
$1.15 each or $12 for 12
Current rotating flavors: Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Crinkle, and Snickerdoodle
Gluten sensitive flavors: Chocolate Chip $1.40 each or $15 for 12
Cookie Pies
$3.45 each or $18 for 6 or $36 for 12
Our Award-Winning Oatmeal Cream Pies, Monster Cookie Pies, and Peanut Butter Cookie Pies
Brownies
$4
Decadent fudgy base covered in a rich chocolate ganache topped with mini chocolate candies
Muffins
$4
Jumbo and perfectly moist for breakfast or a sweet snack. Current rotating flavor: Pumpkin Cheesecake Swirl
10 Inch Cheesecakes
$30, $35
Creamy vanilla cheesecake in a graham cracker crust available in Cherry, Chocolate Chip, Plain, and Turtle
Energy Bites
$1.25 each
A protein-packed blend of crunchy peanut butter, rolled oats, chia and flax seeds, sunflower kernels, mini chocolate chips and a touch of honey
Murphy Bites
4 oz bag for $5 or 16 oz bag for $19
A crunchy, satisfying dog biscuit made with rolled ground oats, pumpkin, peanut butter, and eggs
Our Savory Menu
$35 Family Size and $7.50 for Single Serve
Chicken Pot Pie
Available on Wednesdays only. Order early as they sell out quickly. These are take and bake. White meat chicken, red potatoes, peas, carrots, celery, onions in a rich, creamy sauce covered with our buttery, flaky top crust.
Fiesta Taco Pie
Available on Fridays only. Order early as they sell out quickly. These are take and bake. Seasoned ground beef with tomatoes, black and pinto beans, jalapenos, corn, green chilies, queso fresco and fiesta cheddar cheeses covered with our buttery, flaky top crust.
Quiche
Available to order any day, but please allow 48 hours. Roasted Vegetable with Feta, Ham and Swiss, or Sausage and Cheddar
Create Your Own with Sausage, Ham, Mushrooms, Peppers, Broccoli, Onions, Sundried Tomatoes, Spinach, Cheddar, Feta or Swiss.
Available in gluten sensitive: $40 Family Size and $8.50 for Single Serve